My Fav would be V2 the others are too dark for me the good things would be focal placement and bad things would be a few too much smudging if that's the effect you used and no lighting.
thanks legokiba213, i have been having a problem with lighting effects so i am trying to cut that out
a simple trick was told to me a long back is to make the edges darker, so i left a whole space there
was that right or wrong?
how to make a lighting source?
I like to make a new layer take a 100px soft brush choose white as foreground color then lower the opacity. Next make a new layer same brush this time use a yellow foreground set layer to overlay lower opacity and a nice light should appear. there is also such thing as natural lighting and sometimes you don't need lighting also choose a good spot for lighting don't just place it anywhere.
yea, i know that method... i have been told about it as well (i needed a lot of help about flow and light source in an older gfx forum) the tutorial you showed is great, thanks!