LOL i think they're both ugly, i work at Footlocker and i have never seen these types of shoes anywhere near the store.
But shii go with the less ugly one, the second one. Good luck on finding your summer shoes.
I'm assuming you're into basketball shoes or something of the type (Air Jordans, Hyperdunks, etc,) so these probably aren't your style. I wouldn't say they're ugly, though. I happen to wear shoes like this quite often, and they're also similar to what I'm required to wear at school, too.