Before I start, I want to say this is all personal preference and I don't mean to offend your review or opinion.
I saw them live a few weeks ago, I completely disagree of this being their best album.
Ever since OM&M's debut album I have been a fan, however The Flood in my opinion had a distinct sound to it, Austin having changed his screams in that album I could live with, however ever since this album I've been slowly drifting away from OM&M.
To be completely honest, I dislike Aaron Pauley, I preferred Shayley and it seems that this album is more of Aaron than Austin, when I saw them live Austin was just blindlessly jumping around or screaming random notes to try and fit into some of the songs somewhere. When I saw them a few years ago with Shayley, the atmosphere was completely different and the quality of the show was amazing.
As harsh as this sounds, I feel like Austin is trying to replicate Oli Sykes in some songs, they have the same tone and atmosphere.
I agree this album is a good listen, but I just can't say that it's their best. When the album was announced and was said to be the "Heaviest album produced by them yet" I had my hopes up for a Product Of A Murderer/The Depths type of album, however it wasn't.