I'd suggest if you would like to see positive feedback, take some tutorials, do some actual GFX work not little Rs sigs for account shops. Do some real Gfx lol.
On the other hand, I personally don't believe that first one is very good. Blurry, has no flow, etc.
Google Photoshop: What is Flow? Photoshop: What is Blending? Photoshop: How to use lighting? Etc.
I used to do sigs like yours with images of stuff in say like A GDI Marine from C&C and it had some nice flow effects and lighting but I got bored of them in the end.
Text Sigs are the way forward Good start though mate.
definitely better still empty back ground no depth the render is low detail and yeah. also your not a trusted member so i wouldnt put that in your sig lol
if you're making these fro scratch which usually look pretty cool, download brushes, you cant make a render high detail you just have to find a better picture. Maybe its just me the whole Full dragon look doesn't look good at all
1. Save it as .png, have it interlaced.
2. Look up tutorials, BASIC tutorials, e.g proper blending, color combination, flow, etc.
3. Gather resources, resources which you can play with, e.g brushes, styles, shapes, patterns, stocks, renders.
I always save as .png and always interlace it so it will make the image look better, and I downloaded brushes and patterns too, but for some reason it wont let me add stuff to my font folder.
Yo just a tip, for THREE and FOUR... When you mirror the cloned text (Im guessing is how you did it) When you put it under there, change the transparency a bit lower, it looks more like a reflection